Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano Menu (2025 Update)

Discover the essence of Italian cuisine at Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano, a hidden gem located in Pompton Plains, NJ. This family-owned establishment prides itself on authentic flavors and delightful dishes that cater to everyone. The menu showcases signature creations like the Zuppa Di Pesce, featuring an abundance of seafood in a rich marinara sauce, and the Parmesan Crusted Chicken, perfectly seared to highlight its savory notes.

The diverse offerings extend to delicious pizzas, including the classic Sicilian Plain Cheese Pizza, allowing diners to customize their experience. Patrons rave about the cozy atmosphere and attentive service, making it ideal for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. Whether it's the succulent mussels or expertly crafted pasta dishes, every bite tells a story of culinary passion. Embrace the joy of Italian dining at Pizza Man, where every meal is a celebration.

Pizza by the Slice

Plain Cheese Pizza Slice

US$2.60

Round Plain Cheese Pizza (Large 16")

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

US$14.99

Sicilian Plain Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

US$19.95

Round Plain Cheese Pizza (Personal 10")

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

US$10.99

From Over Pizza Oven

Soups

Tortelloni En Brodo Soup

US$9.95

Stracciatella Romano Soup

US$9.95

Veal Sorrento

Layered with batter dipped eggplant, imported prosciutto and topped with provolone cheese in a light sherry tomato broth with pasta.

US$26.95

Veal Broccoli Rabe Sicilian

Tender veal scallopini, sauteed broccoli rabe, sundried tomatoes, sauteed garlic, olive oil with rigatoni pasta.

US$26.95

Veal Francese

Egg battered, lemon, Chablis and butter over pasta.

US$25.95

Veal Primavera

Garden fresh vegetables sauteed in a pink cognac cream sauce over capellini.

US$26.95

Veal Antonio

Layered with meats, ricotta, eggplant with tomato sauce and mozzarella, served with pasta.

US$20.95

Veal Marsala

Scallopini, marsala wine demi-glace, mushrooms, with pasta.

US$25.95

Veal Parmigiana

Breaded cutlet in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella, with linguine.

US$25.95

Veal Giambotta

Sauteed with “veal” sausage, bell peppers, sweet onions and cherry peppers in a sherry wine demi-glace sauce finished with fried potatoes.

US$26.95

Veal Murphy

Sweet and hot peppers, onion, mushrooms, served with capellini.

US$25.95

Veal Piccata

Scallopini, capers, chablis, lemon demi-glace with pasta.

US$25.95

Veal Margarita

Cutlet, in a pink sauce with mushrooms, ham and provolone cheese with pasta.

US$26.95

Veal Campagnola

Cutlet and sausage with fresh garden vegetables in a pink sauce with pasta.

US$26.95

Veal Cacciatore

Mushrooms, onions, peppers in a hearty tomato sauce with linguine.

US$21.95

Veal Dishes

Our Fabulous Calzone

Calzone

Ours boasts a blend of cheese and finely chopped domestic ham and Genoa salami.

US$11.95

Eggplant Rollatini

Thinly sliced, egg battered, stuffed with three cheese ricotta, salami and ham.

US$19.95

Eggplant Parmigiana

Breaded in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella, served with linguine.

US$19.95

Stuffed Eggplant

Stuffed with three cheese ricotta, salami and ham, baked and topped with mozzarella.

US$19.95

Eggplant Dishes

Chicken Dishes

Chicken Murphy

Sweet and hot peppers, onion, mushrooms, served with capellini.

US$22.95

Chicken Antonio

Layered with meats, ricotta, eggplant with tomato sauce and mozzarella, served with pasta.

US$18.95

Chicken Francese

Egg battered, lemon, Chablis and butter over pasta.

US$21.95

Chicken Margarita

Cutlet, in a pink sauce with mushrooms, ham and provolone cheese with pasta.

US$20.85

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded cutlet in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella, with linguine.

US$19.95

Chicken Sorrento

Layered with batter dipped eggplant, imported prosciutto and topped with provolone cheese in a light sherry tomato broth with pasta.

US$23.95

Chicken Giambotta

Sauteed with “veal” sausage, bell peppers, sweet onions and cherry peppers in a sherry wine demi-glace sauce finished with fried potatoes.

US$23.95

Chicken Marsala

Scallopini, marsala wine demi-glace, mushrooms, with pasta.

US$21.95

Chicken Primavera

Garden fresh vegetables sauteed in a pink cognac cream sauce over capellini.

US$23.95

Chicken Cacciatore

Mushrooms, onions, peppers in a hearty tomato sauce with linguine.

US$19.95

Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sicilian

Tender chicken scallopini, sauteed broccoli rabe, sundried tomatoes, sauteed garlic, olive oil with rigatoni pasta.

US$23.95

Chicken Piccata

Scallopini, capers, chablis, lemon demi-glace with pasta.

US$21.95

Chicken Campagnola

Cutlet and sausage with fresh garden vegetables in a pink sauce with pasta.

US$23.95

House Salad

No meat or fish.

US$10.95

Fresh Tomato, Mozzarella & Bermuda Onion Salad

Red ripe garden tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and thinly sliced red onion in a garlic vinaigrette dressing.

US$15.95

Caesar Salad

Homemade Caesar dressing.

US$9.95

Antipasto Salad

The traditional start of the real Italian meal; ours is a classic, an imported selection of meats, cheese, and salad, dressed with our own oil & vinegar mix.

US$12.95

House Salad Large Portion

US$15.95

Antipasto Salad Small Portion

The traditional start of the real Italian meal; ours is a classic, an imported selection of meats, cheese, and salad, dressed with our own oil & vinegar mix.

US$12.95

House Salad Small Portion

No meat or fish.

US$10.95

Salads

Appetizers

Sauteed Broccoli Rabe

Sauteed.

US$14.95

Garlic Bread

The perfect start to your meal. Our blend of herbs and spices topped with melted mozzarella.

US$4.75

Risotto Balls

Deep-fried breaded risotto croquettes filled with beef in a hearty marinara sauce.

US$15.95

Sauteed Spinach & Mushrooms

US$11.95

Fried Calamari

Served with cocktail & tomato sauce.

US$15.95

Breaded Artichoke Heart Bosciola

In a pink cream sauce with bacon, prosciutto, onion, mushrooms and green peas.

US$16.95

Clams Zuppa

A savory, made-to-order shellfish treat - small, tender clams steamed whole in the shell in a delicately spiced marinara sauce.

US$19.95

Garlic Bread Half

The perfect start to your meal. Our blend of herbs and spices topped with melted mozzarella.

US$4.75

Garlic Bread Whole

US$6.75

Two Plain Pizzas

US$19.99

Wednesday Special Plain Cheese Pizza 9.99

US$9.99

Featured Deal

Risotto

Al Funghi Risotto

Wild mushrooms, marsala wine, fresh thyme & Grana Padano cheese.

US$19.95

Fruitti Di Mare Risotto

Shrimp, mussels, clams in a lobster sauce.

US$28.95

Caprese Risotto

Pesto, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, onions and filetto di pomodoro.

US$18.95

Round BBQ Chicken Pizza (Personal 10")

With round BBQ chicken.

US$15.95

Round Chicken Parmigiana Pizza (Personal 10")

With round chicken.

US$15.95

Round Ricotta & Broccoli Pizza (Personal 10")

With ricotta & broccoli.

US$15.95

Round Shrimp Scampi Pizza (Large 16")

With shrimp scampi.

US$21.95

Round BBQ Chicken Pizza (Large 16")

With round BBQ chicken.

US$20.95

Round Shrimp Scampi Pizza (Personal 10")

With shrimp scampi.

US$16.95

Round Vegetable Pizza (Personal 10")

With vegetables.

US$14.95

Round Pizza Man Special Pizza (Personal 10")

Special.

US$15.95

Round Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Large 16")

With buffalo chicken.

US$20.95

Round Hawaiian Pizza (Personal 10")

Ham & pineapple.

US$14.95

Round Margarita Pizza (Personal 10")

With cheese.

US$15.95

Round Margarita Pizza (Large 16")

With cheese.

US$20.95

Round Hawaiian Pizza (Large 16")

Ham & pineapple.

US$19.95

Round Ricotta & Broccoli Pizza (Large 16")

With ricotta & broccoli.

US$21.95

Round Pizza Man Special Pizza (Large 16")

Special.

US$22.95

Round Vegetable Pizza (Large 16")

With vegetables.

US$21.95

Round Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Personal 10")

With buffalo chicken.

US$15.95

Round Chicken Parmigiana Pizza (Large 16")

With round chicken.

US$20.95

Specialty Round Pizza

Sicilian Specialty Pizza

Sicilian BBQ Chicken Pizza

With BBQ chicken.

US$26.95

Sicilian Ricotta & Broccoli Pizza

Ricotta & broccoli.

US$25.95

Sicilian Pizza Man Special Pizza

Special.

US$27.95

Sicilian Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

With chicken parmigiana.

US$26.95

Sicilian Margarita Pizza

With cheese.

US$25.95

Sicilian Shrimp Scampi Pizza

With shrimp scampi.

US$26.95

Sicilian Buffalo Chicken Pizza

With buffalo chicken.

US$26.95

Sicilian Vegetable Pizza

With vegetables.

US$25.95

Sicilian Hawaiian Pizza

Ham & pineapple.

US$23.95

Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich

With meatball parmigiana.

US$10.95

Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich

With provolone, lettuce & tomato.

US$12.05

Nero’s Hero Sandwich

Imported ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and our house vinaigrette.

US$12.05

Sausage Parmigiana Sandwich

With sausage parmigiana.

US$10.95

Sausage, Peppers & Onions Sandwich

With sausage, peppers & onions.

US$10.95

Sausage Sandwich

With sausage.

US$9.85

Veal Parmigiana Sandwich

The REAL veal.

US$14.25

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

With provolone, lettuce & tomato.

US$12.05

Meatball Sandwich

With meatball.

US$9.85

Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich

With provolone, lettuce & tomato.

US$12.05

Classic Sandwiches

Fish Dishes

Shrimp Parmigiana

Breaded jumbo shrimp in a hearty tomato sauce, served over pasta.

US$22.95

Shrimp & Clams Roma

Jumbo shrimp and clams in a delicate pink garlic sauce, served over imported linguine.

US$28.95

Mussels Bianco

In a white wine sauce, with onions, served over linguine.

US$23.95

Linguine With White Clams Sauce

An aromatic fusion of fresh clams, garlic, extra virgin olive oil and basil over linguine.

US$23.95

Calamari

Tossed in a marinara sauce over linguine.

US$17.95

Clams Bianco

In a white wine sauce, with onions, served over linguine.

US$23.95

Shrimp Scampi

Jumbo shrimp, lemon, Chablis and butter over pasta.

US$22.95

Linguine With Red Clams Sauce

An aromatic fusion of fresh clams, garlic, extra virgin olive oil and basil over linguine.

US$23.95

Shrimp Norman

Jumbo shrimp lightly coated with oreganato breadcrumbs, sauteed in garlic, buttter, white wine and lemon sauce over imported linguine.

US$22.95

12 Pieces Clams Zuppa Entree

Littleneck clams in a hearty marinara sauce over linguine.

US$23.95

Linguine With Red Sauce

An aromatic fusion of fresh clams, garlic, extra virgin olive oil and basil over linguine.

US$23.95

Linguine With White Sauce

An aromatic fusion of fresh clams, garlic, extra virgin olive oil and basil over linguine.

US$23.95

Pasta & Salad

US$29.90

Pasta & Soup

US$29.90

Pasta Pairs

Create Your Own Pizza At Home

Marinara Pizza At Home

US$14.95

Pasta Verde Bosciola

Spinach fettuccine in a pink cream sauce with bacon, prosciutto, onion, mushrooms and green peas.

US$20.95

Stuffed Jumbo Shells

US$16.95

Vodka Rigatoni

Sauteed in a fresh basil garlic cream sauce, finished with fresh parmesan cheese and swiss cheese.

US$19.95

Stuffed Rigatoni

Ricotta filled pasta served in a brandy cream and grated cheese sauce.

US$19.95

Tortellini Bolognese

Cheese filled tortellini in a pink brandy cream sauce with chopped sausage and grated cheeses.

US$19.95

Homemade Oven Baked Lasagna

US$17.95

Fettuccine Carbonara

White fettuccine noodles with onion, bacon, prosciutto, Chablis, mushrooms and grated cheese.

US$19.95

Meat Ravioli

With meat.

US$17.95

Cavatelli Alla Ripini

Ricotta cavatelli with sauteed broccoli rabe, sausage and cherry peppers in a sherry wine butter sauce.

US$20.95

Cavateli & Broccoli

Ricotta cavatelli and broccoli florets sauteed in a white wine garlic sauce, finished with basil and diced tomatoes.

US$19.95

Linguine With Marinara Sauce

With marinara sauce.

US$15.95

Linguine With Meat Sauce

With meat sauce.

US$17.95

Gnocchi Quattro Formaggio

Potato dumplings cooked in a pink brandy sauce finished in a combination of four kinds of cheese.

US$19.95

Cheese Ravioli

With cheese.

US$16.95

Linguine With Tomato Sauce

With tomato sauce.

US$13.95

Tortellini Alfredo

Cheese filled tortellini in fresh cream, butter and imported parmesan and romano cheese sauce.

US$19.95

Linguine With Meatballs

With meatballs.

US$17.95

Baked Ziti Parmigiana

US$16.95

Gnocchi Pesto

Potato dumplings tossed in a fusion of fresh basil, garlic, herbs, and spices, finished with sweet creamy butter and heavy cream.

US$19.95

Pasta

Beverages

Raspberry Iced Tea

US$1.50

Coffee

US$1.95

Bottled Water

US$2.20

Iced Tea

US$3.30

All Natural Soda

US$3.30

San Pellegrino

US$7.65

Raspberry Tea

US$2.50

Juice

US$1.50

Cappuccino

US$3.50

Fountain Soda

US$1.50

Soda

US$2.20

Tea

US$3.30

Hot Chocolate

US$1.95

Parmesan Crusted Chicken Breast

Pan seared with sauteed spinach and rosemary roasted potatoes in a lemon butter sauce.

US$26.95

Zuppa Di Pesce

Jumbo shrimp, clams, mussels, sole, calamari and scallops in a marinara sauce over imported linguine.

US$30.95

Shrimp & Scallops Pomodoro

Parmesan crusted day boat scallops and shrimp with crushed tomatoes, sauteed garlic and fresh basil mixed with pappardelle pasta.

US$28.95

Santa Lucia

Jumbo shrimp, calamari, clams and mussels in a delicate pink garlic sauce, served over imported linguine.

US$28.95

Pasta Festival

Chicken, shrimp, sundried tomatoes, black olives, heavy cream, brandy, mushrooms and fresh broccoli with farfalle pasta.

US$26.95

Chicken Milanese

Topped with a cold melange of arugula, roasted peppers, tomato, red onion and fresh mozzarella tossed in our signature balsamic vinaigrette.

US$18.95

Chicken & Shrimp Pequannock

Sauteed in a light garlic wine and butter sauce with fresh herbs, capers, roasted peppers and artichoke hearts, served over pappardelle pasta.

US$26.95

Pizza Man Trio

Stuffed eggplant, lasagna roll, and veal parmigiana, oven baked, topped with mozzarella.

US$27.95

Chicken & Shrimp Putanesca

Olives, roasted peppers, anchovies, capers, pepperoncini, white wine and fresh basil over pappardelle pasta.

US$21.95

Pizzaman Signature Dishes

Sides

Side Of Meatballs (2 Pieces)

US$6.50

Side Of Sausage (2 Pieces)

US$6.50

French Fries With Mozzarella & Brown Gravy

With mozzarella & brown gravy.

US$7.95

Sauteed Broccoli

US$10.95

Mozzarella Sticks

Served with tomato sauce.

US$9.95

Side Of Pasta

With tomato sauce.

US$6.50

French Fries

Our delicious French fries are deep fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

US$4.50